4.10.18

How To Choose The Right Pair of Running Shoes

*updated 4/26/2019

To get the most out of your run, you need a pair of shoes to help your body operate as efficiently as possible (while remaining comfortable). The first step to choosing the right pair of running shoes is understanding how your feet work.

Choosing The Right Running Shoes Lifestyle

The Science Of Your Stride

With every step, you generate force that must be absorbed and distributed across your foot and through your entire body. To safely do this, your foot becomes flexible upon impact, expanding and rolling slightly inward (this action is also referred to as pronation). As you move through your stride towards toe-off, your foot then becomes more rigid as the muscles and ligaments in your legs prepare to launch you forward into your next step. This entire process (known as your gait cycle) happens in less than a second.

With so many moving parts, it’s no surprise that achieving a smooth, natural stride is easier said than done. The mechanics of running are unique to every person, but it’s important to remember that everybody pronates. It’s the foot’s natural motion. So when deciding on the best type of shoe for your feet, it’s best not to ask, “Do my feet pronate?” but rather, “How much do my feet pronate?” Some feet roll in too far (overpronation) while others don’t become flexible enough (supination). And without the right shoes, both can cause discomfort or leave you vulnerable to injury.

So, what’s the best way to find out how your foot operates? That’s easy. All you need is a piece of paper and a little water.

The Footprint Test

1. Wet the bottom of your foot.
2. Step onto the piece of paper.

Just like that, you have all the information you need to choose the right pair of running shoes. Let’s look at your footprint:

Choose The Right Running Shoe 3

Arch Types

Flat

Can you see the full outline of your foot? Then that means you have low arches (commonly known as flat feet). Flat feet tend to flex more than other arch types and are more likely to overpronate. Since your feet don’t have as much natural arch support, you’ll need to find shoes to provide that support for you during the gait cycle. Look for motion control or stability shoes to help stabilize your feet and prevent injury.

Medium

If your footprint shows the ball and heel of your foot connected by a wide band, you have medium arches and plenty of options for shoes that will work with your foot type. Try neutral shoes or stability shoes for a little extra support.

High

If your footprint shows a very narrow band (or perhaps no band) between the heel and ball of your foot, you have high arches. Feet with high arches pronate less than other arch types and can tend towards supination (the outward rolling of the heel upon impact). This makes it difficult for your body to safely absorb the force you create with each step. The best shoe type for you is a neutral running shoe with plenty of cushioning.

Nike Free RN 5.0

The Shoe Types

Motion Control

So, you’ve discovered that your flat feet overpronate (roll too far inward). Without the right pair of shoes, this action can put extra stress on your joints and muscles. Motion control running shoes are designed to stabilize your feet. Usually, these shoes will have posts or wedges in the midsole that support flat feet and help limit motion, especially on the inside of your foot.

Our Top Picks: Brooks Beast 18, Brooks Addiction 13, Saucony Omni ISO

Stability

Finding a stability running shoe is key if you have semi-flat or medium arches. Though you may be in the sweet spot of pronation with your normal stride, a little extra support never hurts, especially since feet are more likely to overpronate as your body tires. So if you’re in it for the long haul, a stability shoe is a great choice for fighting that fatigue. These shoes pair light, responsive foam with firmer midsole materials, combining cushioning and support to keep you running strong and injury free.

Our Top Picks: Asics GEL Kayano 25, Brooks Adrenaline GTS 19, Mizuno Wave Inspire 15

Neutral

If you’re a high-arched runner with a tendency to supinate, it’s best to find a shoe to enhance your natural running mechanics. Neutral running shoes are lightweight and comfortably cushioned. They’re all about a smooth ride and allowing your foot to move naturally, so they feature soft, responsive midsoles that return energy with every step.

Our Top Picks: Asics Nimbus 21, Brooks Ghost 11, Nike Free RN 3.0/5.0

For more shoe recommendations check out Eastbay’s best running shoes of the year.

3 Comments

  • Frankie:

    I’m going to get a new shoes

  • Christopher Pryor:

    Great read!! Definitely have been trying to find a shoe that fits my needs as a runner! This has helped me a tremendous amount to move in the best direction!

  • Fritz Loban:

    What shoes are good for tendonitis …. in basketball shoes and what shoes are for running and walking

Female cross country runner running with trees in background

Best Cross Country Shoes for Practice and Competition

Cross country season is here, and we've got the fastest spikes around so that you can set new personal bests and dominate every meet.

Brooks Beasts Team Training Feature Image

Benefits of a Running Team, According to the Brooks Beasts

By training as a running team instead of individual athletes, the Brooks Beasts Track Club provides its athletes with unique benefits.

Nike Zoom Story Feature Image

The Differences Between the Nike Zoom Shoes

Discover the differences between all the Nike Zoom running shoes to find out which pairs suits you best.

Katie Mackey Feature Image

5 Warmup Do’s and Don’ts from Katie Mackey

Katie Mackey, 1500m and 5K runner for the Brooks Beasts, shares her tips for what to do (and not to do) during warm ups.

Coach Danny Mackey Feature Image

A Running Coach’s Perspective

Danny Mackey, head coach of the Brooks Beasts Track Club, shares thoughts on how he prepares his team for success.

Nike ZoomX Vaporfly NEXT% Feature

Release Report: Nike ZoomX Vaporfly NEXT%

Read about the new features of the Nike ZoomX Vaporfly NEXT%. The shoe created to help marathon runners rewrite record books.

Best Long-Distance Running Shoes Feature

Best Long-Distance Running Shoes

Looking for a fresh pair of long-distance running shoes for the summer season? Check out our list of the best!

Updated Feature Best Kids' Running Shoes

Best Kids’ Running Shoes

Stress less and run more with a pair of shoes from our list of best kids' running shoes.

2019 Best Running Shoes

Best Running Shoes 2019

As you go through your closet for spring cleaning, replace your worn out running shoes with a new pair! Here's the year's best running shoes from Eastbay.

Des Linden Feature

It Takes Two: Desiree Linden and Brooks Glycerin

Desiree Linden, winner of the 2018 Boston Marathon, talks about her favorite Brooks running shoes and how they help her succeed.

Noah Lyles, Professional Sprinter

5 Keys to Success from Noah Lyles

Noah Lyles, Eastbay's March cover athlete, gives advice on how to stay in your lane and find success on and off the track.

Best Track and Field Shoes: A 2019 Guide

Conquer the season with the best track and field shoes from Eastbay. Here's an informative guide to help you find the right shoes for your competition.

See More